Calculator · compare

    Compare private mortgage offers and the alternatives

    Short answer

    Compare a private second, a private first, a B-lender refinance, a HELOC or selling on one yardstick: what you'd have left at the end of the period after every payment, fee and penalty. A cheaper rate on a bigger loan can lose to a pricier second that keeps a low-rate first in place.

    The cheapest-looking rate isn't always the cheapest option. Refinancing everything into one private first means breaking a low-rate mortgage and paying fees on the whole balance; a second leaves the first alone but costs more per dollar. A HELOC or a B-lender may be cheaper if you qualify, and selling ends the borrowing altogether. Compare them on one yardstick.

    Mitey the yeti comparing two loan offers, one in each paw
    Mitey holds two offers side by side and asks what each leaves you with at the end.
    Your situation
    Usually the private term
    Test 0% and a decline
    Your current first mortgage
    Estimate a penalty

    Starting figures are illustrative, not quotes. Replace them with your offers; nothing you type is sent anywhere.

    Keep my first, add a private second

    Payments
    Net position after 12 months
    $264,038
    • Monthly outlay$3,437
    • Upfront costs$5,670
    • New borrowing$105,670
    • Interest over the period$30,292
    • Debt at the end$494,717
    • Combined LTV63.2%
    • All-in cost, new money19.44%
    • Check that your first mortgage allows a second charge; some standard terms treat it as default.

    Refinance everything into a private first

    Payments
    Net position after 12 months
    $222,021
    • Monthly outlay$4,179
    • Upfront costs$27,835
    • New borrowing$527,835
    • Interest over the period$50,144
    • Debt at the end$527,835
    • Combined LTV66.0%
    • All-in cost, new money14.18%
    • Includes the $9,000 penalty to break your current mortgage.

    Keep my first, add a HELOC

    Net position after 12 months
    $275,833
    Best on these numbers
    • Monthly outlay$2,843
    • Upfront costs$1,000
    • New borrowing$101,000
    • Interest over the period$23,167
    • Debt at the end$490,047
    • Combined LTV62.6%
    • All-in cost, new money6.72%
    • A HELOC from a bank or credit union means passing their income and credit checks, including the stress test.
    How to read "net position". It is what you'd have at the end of the period: the property's value (if you still own it) minus all debt still owing, minus every payment or rent paid along the way. The cash you need is the same in every option, so it's left out. Higher is better. It is a like-for-like yardstick, not a forecast.
    Keep a 4.29% first, or refinance it all at 9.25%?

    A homeowner with a $380,000 first at 4.29% needs $90,000. Option one adds a private second at 11.75%; option two refinances everything into a private first at 9.25%, paying an $8,200 penalty.

    Keep a 4.29% first, or refinance it all at 9.25%?: inputs, steps and result
    Property$760,000no value change assumed over 12 months
    Current first$380,000 at 4.29%penalty to break it $8,200
    Cash needed$90,000
    Keep my first, add a private second$95,361 new loan$3,216 a month; $463,906 owed at the end
    Refinance everything into a private first$496,082 new loan$3,824 a month; $496,082 owed at the end
    Better net position after 12 monthsKeep the first, add a secondby $39,468

    The second costs more per dollar, but only on $90,000; refinancing puts the whole balance at 9.25% and adds the penalty and fees on a much bigger loan.

    Compare your own options →Computed by this site's comparison engine (net position: value minus debt minus payments).

    How does the compare offers work?

    One yardstick: net position

    For each option the tool works out what you would have at the end of the period: the property's value if you still own it, minus every debt still owing, minus every payment (or rent) along the way. The cash you need is the same in each option, so it drops out. The option with the higher net position cost you less.

    Private first vs private second

    A new first must pay out your existing mortgage, its penalty, the fees and your cash need, with fees grossed up because they come off the advance. A second only covers the cash and its own fees, and your existing first keeps amortizing at its own rate.

    HELOC and B-lender checks

    A HELOC beyond FCAC's typical limits (65% of value on its own, 80% of value with the mortgage) is marked as likely unavailable. B-lender and bank options show the stress-test rate you'd need to qualify at.

    What it doesn't do

    • A comparison of costs, not of approval: banks, B-lenders and HELOC providers apply their own underwriting.
    • Assumes the existing first continues on its terms, and that each private option is repaid at the end of the period.
    • Value changes are an assumption you set; test a decline.

    Calculations run in your browser and nothing you type is sent anywhere. Method and formulas: how we calculate. Reviewed November 2, 2026.

    What do people ask most?

    Is a second mortgage cheaper than refinancing into a private first?

    Often, when your current first has a low rate and a moderate penalty, because the expensive money is limited to the amount you need. When the first is small, its rate is high or the penalty is large, one new first can win. The tool shows which on your numbers.

    Should I consider selling instead of borrowing privately?

    If the private loan only delays a sale that's coming anyway, the interest and fees are a cost of waiting. Compare the net position of selling now, including selling costs and rent, with borrowing for the period.

    How much can I borrow on a HELOC?

    FCAC says a HELOC can usually go up to 65% of the home's value, and total borrowing secured by the home usually up to 80%. You also need to qualify with the lender.