What are the key takeaways?
- Start by finding out exactly why a conventional lender said no, because the fix depends on the reason.
- Use the private term to build verifiable evidence: on-time payments, documented income and lower debts.
- Expect a federally regulated lender to qualify you at a rate above your contract rate, and run your numbers at that rate early.
- Talk to a licensed mortgage professional several months before maturity, not in the final weeks.
01Why were you declined, and what fixes it?
Conventional lenders decline applications for a handful of broad reasons, and each one has a different remedy. Before you plan anything, find out which applied to you. If a broker placed your private loan, ask them what the bank-side issue was. If you applied directly, ask the lender. Write the answer down; it is the problem your plan has to solve.
- Credit history: late payments, collections, a recent consumer proposal or bankruptcy, or a thin file.
- Income documentation: income that is real but hard to prove, common for self-employed borrowers, commission earners and new arrivals.
- Debt-service ratios: too much monthly debt relative to income at the qualifying rate.
- Equity: not enough equity for the loan needed, or a property type a conventional lender would not finance.
- Timing: a deal that had to close faster than a conventional approval could be arranged.
02What does a 6 to 12 month plan look like?
The steps below assume a twelve-month private term. If yours is shorter, compress the early steps; if it is longer, use the extra time to strengthen the weakest part of your file.
- Month 0: write the target. Record the decline reason, the private loan's maturity date and the balance that will be owing then. Note what a refinance needs to look like: loan amount, property value and the income required to qualify.
- Month 1: get your credit reports. Request your reports from both national credit bureaus, check every account, and dispute anything inaccurate in writing.
- Month 1: start your document folder. Employed borrowers: recent pay stubs, an employment letter and the last two notices of assessment. Self-employed borrowers: personal tax returns and notices of assessment for recent years, business financial statements and evidence that taxes are paid up.
- Months 1 to 12: pay everything on time. Make every mortgage, card and loan payment on or before the due date, and keep proof of private mortgage payments, since that lender may not report to the credit bureaus.
- Months 2 to 8: reduce other debts. Pay down revolving balances and, where possible, clear small loans with high monthly payments. Lower monthly obligations improve the debt-service ratios a refinance lender will calculate.
- Months 2 to 12: avoid new credit. Hold off on new car loans, credit cards or financing offers you do not need, as each can add a payment and an inquiry.
- Months 3 to 9: protect and build equity. If the loan allows prepayments, use spare cash to pay down principal. Keep up maintenance and finish any work that affects value.
- Month 6: file taxes on time and check them. If you are self-employed, talk to your accountant about how your reported income will look to a lender before you file.
- Months 6 to 8: speak with a licensed mortgage professional. Ask them to review your file against the lenders you are aiming for and to run your numbers at the qualifying rate.
- Months 8 to 10: apply and order an appraisal if requested. Give yourself time for conditions, document requests and a second option if the first lender declines.
- Months 10 to 12: coordinate the payout. Give the private lender any required notice, request a payout statement, and have your lawyer or notary arrange the discharge.
- Throughout: keep a fallback. Ask your private lender early what an extension would cost, so a delay has a known price.
03How do you make your income easy to verify?
A conventional lender has to be able to verify your income from documents it accepts. Income that exists but is not on paper may not count. For employed borrowers, that usually means a stable job past any probation period and documents that match. For the self-employed, it often means income declared on tax returns over a period of time, so the way you report income in the year before you refinance matters. An accountant can explain the trade-offs between minimizing tax and maximizing qualifying income.
If income was the reason for your decline, ask a licensed mortgage professional what period of history the lenders you are targeting may want to see, and whether your private term is long enough to build it. Our documents private lenders ask for guide is a useful starting checklist, since conventional lenders tend to ask for similar paperwork.
04How do payment history and credit help?
A full term of on-time payments can be persuasive evidence for a lender after a credit problem. Make sure the evidence exists. Some private lenders do not report to the credit bureaus, so keep bank statements showing each mortgage payment leaving your account on time, and ask the lender whether it will provide a payment history letter at the end of the term.
Keep credit card balances well below their limits, and keep older accounts open if they are in good standing. If you had a consumer proposal or bankruptcy, keep the completion or discharge paperwork with your file, because the next lender will ask for it.
05How do equity and the qualifying test fit together?
Take an illustrative borrower in Edmonton with a $295,000 private first mortgage at 9.5% on a home worth $445,000. The year in the private loan costs $35,925 in interest and fees. At maturity, a refinance of $295,000 is 66.3% loan-to-value, comfortably under an illustrative 80% limit. (The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada notes that total borrowing secured by a home is usually limited to 80% of its value, though that is a typical lender limit rather than a law.)
The next hurdle is the qualifying rate. Under OSFI's Guideline B-20, federally regulated lenders qualify uninsured mortgage borrowers at the greater of the contract rate plus two percentage points or 5.25%. OSFI reviews the rate at least annually, so check the current figure before you apply. At an assumed contract rate of 4.69%, the qualifying rate is 6.69%, giving a qualifying payment of $2,010 a month against an actual payment of $1,664. With the borrower's illustrative income, property taxes, heating and a $420 car payment, the debt-service ratios are 31.0% (GDS) and 36.4% (TDS). Clear the car loan before applying, and TDS falls to 31.0%. Lenders compare ratios like these with their own limits, so ask a licensed mortgage professional where yours need to be. Refinancing and the stress test explains the rule in more detail.
06How does the stress test work at two contract rates?
Consider an illustrative Hamilton homeowner with a $540,000 private first mortgage at 8.99% on a home worth $760,000. The private year costs $59,346 in interest and fees. At maturity, a $540,000 refinance would be 71.1% loan-to-value. The borrower earns $12,500 a month before tax, pays $480 a month in property tax and $130 in heating, and has $900 a month in other debt payments.
If the bank offers 4.89% over 25 years, the qualifying rate is 6.89% (the contract rate plus 2 points). The qualifying payment is $3,746 a month, while the actual payment would be $3,107. Those figures produce debt-service ratios of 34.8% for housing costs alone (GDS) and 42.0% including other debts (TDS).
Now suppose rates were much lower and the bank offered 3.09%. Adding 2 points would give a rate below 5.25%, so the floor applies instead: the qualifying rate is 5.25%, with a qualifying payment of $3,218 against an actual payment of $2,581, and ratios of 30.6% and 37.8%. At low contract rates, it is the floor rather than the 2-point buffer that sets the test.
| Offered at 4.89% | Offered at 3.09% | |
|---|---|---|
| Qualifying rate | 6.89% | 5.25% |
| Qualifying payment | $3,746 | $3,218 |
| Actual payment | $3,107 | $2,581 |
| GDS at the qualifying rate | 34.8% | 30.6% |
| TDS at the qualifying rate | 42.0% | 37.8% |
07Which levers help when the numbers are tight?
If your ratios do not fit, some changes help more than others. The illustrative examples below use the same Hamilton borrower at the 4.89% offer.
- Clear other monthly debts. Paying off the $900 a month in other debt payments lowers TDS from 42.0% to 34.8%, without changing the mortgage at all.
- Ask about amortization. If a lender offers a 30-year amortization on the refinance, the qualifying payment falls to $3,518 and the ratios to 33.0% and 40.2%. Availability depends on the lender and the mortgage type.
- Borrow less. A smaller refinance lowers the qualifying payment. Paying down the private loan during its term, if prepayments are allowed, can help; see open versus closed private mortgages.
- Document more income. Income that is real but undocumented may not count. Self-employed borrowers should read the self-employed guide and speak with an accountant well before the tax year that will be reviewed.
- Add a co-borrower. A spouse or partner with income may strengthen the application, but they also take on the debt, and should get their own legal advice.
08Does the straight-switch exemption help you leave a private loan?
Since November 21, 2024, OSFI no longer prescribes the minimum qualifying rate for an uninsured straight switch at renewal. A straight switch moves an existing stand-alone uninsured mortgage to another federally regulated lender with no increase in the loan amount or amortization; unpaid principal may rise by up to $3,000 for transaction costs, and equity take-outs are not allowed. The new lender must still underwrite the loan under Guideline B-20.
That description does not match a typical private-mortgage exit. Refinancing a private first into a bank mortgage moves a loan from a lender that is not federally regulated, and consolidating a private second with an existing first increases the amount of the new mortgage. Ask a licensed mortgage professional how your specific refinance will be treated, rather than assuming the exemption applies.
A $450,000 private first on a $640,000 home while a self-employed borrower builds two years of filed income.
| Loan | $450,000 first mortgage12-month term, interest-only |
|---|---|
| Rate | 9.25%compounded monthly |
| Fees | $13,250lender 1.5%, broker 1%, other $2,000, deducted from the advance |
| Property | $640,000loan-to-value 70.3% |
| Clauses | 3 months' minimum interest |
| Credit actually advanced | $436,750loan minus every deducted charge |
| APR on credit advanced | 12.40%Criminal Code s.347 limit: 35% |
| If repaid at month 3 | 21.45%fees spread over fewer months |
| All-in effective annual cost | 13.12% |
| Cost of the term | $54,875interest plus fees; $450,000 still owed at maturity |
| Analyzer verdict | Ask before signing1 point to raise |
- Check Minimum interest of 3 months if you repay early
Open this example in the commitment analyzer →Computed by this site's commitment analyzer (Criminal Code s.347, Interest Act ss.6, 8, 10). Illustrative terms, not an offer.
What does this mean for you?
- Find out exactly why the bank said no; the fix for thin income history is different from the fix for a credit event.
- Run your numbers at the qualifying rate (the higher of the contract rate plus 2 points or 5.25%) months before maturity in the exit planner.
- Avoid a long minimum-interest clause if your bank exit could come early; it can cost months of interest.
What do people ask most?
How long do I need to stay in a private mortgage before going back to a bank?
There is no fixed period. It depends on why you were declined and how long it takes to fix that, such as building income history or re-establishing credit. A licensed mortgage professional can tell you what the lenders you are targeting may look for.
Do private mortgage payments help my credit score?
Only if the lender reports to the credit bureaus, and some do not. Keep your own proof of on-time payments and ask the lender for a payment history letter.
Will I have to pass the stress test to leave a private mortgage?
If you refinance with a federally regulated lender on an uninsured mortgage, you would generally be qualified at the greater of your contract rate plus two percentage points or 5.25%, under OSFI's Guideline B-20.
What if a bank still says no at maturity?
Options may include an alternative lender, an extension with your private lender, or a sale. Ask early about extension costs so you can compare them with the other routes.
What is the mortgage stress test in Canada?
For uninsured mortgages at federally regulated lenders, OSFI requires borrowers to qualify at the greater of the contract rate plus 2 percentage points or 5.25%. You pay the contract rate; the higher rate is used only to test affordability.
Which primary sources back this page?
This guide is general education for Canadians, not financial, legal or tax advice. Figures in examples are illustrative, not offers or market rates. Rules change; confirm current requirements with a licensed mortgage professional and a lawyer (or notary in Quebec).

