What are the key takeaways?
- The tiers differ mainly in funding source, how rigidly they apply qualification rules, and how much flexibility they trade for price.
- B lenders are institutions with more flexible criteria than banks; private lenders lend their own or investors' capital case by case.
- Most borrowers who use a B or private lender plan to move up a tier once the reason they could not qualify has been resolved.
- Keeping a low-cost first mortgage and adding a private second can cost less overall than replacing everything, but not always.
How do banks, B-lenders and private lenders compare?
The table below is a conceptual map rather than a rulebook. Individual lenders within each tier vary, and the lines between tiers blur at the edges: some credit unions behave like prime lenders, others like alternative lenders, and some private lenders are large, well-organized businesses. Treat the tier as a starting point for questions, not a verdict on quality.
| Banks and prime lenders | Alternative (B) lenders | Private lenders | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who they are | Chartered banks and prime-focused credit unions and lenders | Trust companies, some credit unions and alternative mortgage lenders | Individuals, investor groups, MICs and private lending companies |
| Main source of funds | Deposits and institutional funding | Deposits or institutional funding, depending on the lender | Lenders' own capital or pooled investor capital |
| How they assess files | Standardized income, credit and debt-ratio rules | Defined criteria with more room for non-traditional income or recent credit issues | Case by case, weighted toward property, equity and exit |
| What the borrower trades | Strict documentation for lower cost | Some added cost and fees for flexibility | Higher rate and fees for the most flexibility and speed |
| Usual role | Long-term home financing | Medium-term step while credit or income is rebuilt | Short-term bridge to a sale, refinance or move up a tier |
Who are the prime lenders, and what do they need?
Banks are federally regulated deposit-taking institutions. They lend money that ultimately belongs to depositors, so they work within detailed policies on income verification, credit history, debt service ratios and qualifying rates. Many credit unions and some other lenders compete in the same prime space, under their own regulatory frameworks.
For a borrower who fits, prime lending is usually the least expensive option and offers the longest terms and the most predictable renewals. The trade-off is rigidity. Income has to be documented in a prescribed way, credit history needs to be clean enough, and the borrower must pass a qualifying test. For uninsured mortgages, the federal banking regulator, OSFI, requires federally regulated lenders to qualify borrowers at the greater of the mortgage contract rate plus 2% or 5.25%, so the test payment is higher than the real one. If you want to understand how qualifying works when you plan to come back to a bank, read refinancing and the stress test.
What do alternative or B-lenders offer?
Alternative lenders, often called B lenders, sit between banks and private lenders. The group includes trust companies, some credit unions and other institutional mortgage lenders. They still operate within formal underwriting policies, but those policies leave more room for situations banks find difficult: self-employed income shown through bank statements rather than tax returns, a credit event that is a year or two old, or higher debt ratios.
In exchange, borrowers can expect a higher rate than prime, and in some cases a lender fee and a broker fee. Terms may be shorter than at a bank. For many borrowers this tier is the middle rung of a ladder: a place to stabilize while income documentation or credit improves, before moving back to prime. Because B lenders are institutions, their offers tend to arrive through mortgage brokers, so the broker resources on this site are a useful companion.
When do private lenders fit?
Private lenders are not deposit-taking institutions. They lend their own capital or capital raised from investors, which lets them make decisions file by file. The lender might be an individual, a group of individuals lending together, a mortgage investment corporation or a private lending company. The essentials of the product are covered in what is a private mortgage.
Private lenders tend to put the property, the equity and the exit plan ahead of income documentation, and they can often act on short notice. The cost is higher rates, upfront fees that are frequently deducted from the advance, short terms and, in many cases, interest-only payments with the full balance due at maturity. Rules for the brokers who arrange private loans differ by province. In Ontario, for example, FSRA states that private and alternative mortgages require a Level 2 agent or a broker, while a Level 1 agent can arrange only traditional-lender mortgages. See provincial licence lookup directory for where to check a licence.
How do you move between tiers?
The tiers work best when you think of them as a path rather than a permanent label. A borrower might use a private loan to close a time-sensitive purchase, move to a B lender once the old home sells and the file is cleaner, and return to a bank after two years of documented income. Each step should lower the cost of borrowing.
That path does not happen by itself. Before taking a B or private loan, ask what specifically stands between you and the next tier, how long fixing it should take, and what the next lender will want to see. The guide on how to get back to a bank breaks that into steps. If no one can explain the route up, the loan may be filling a gap that will still be there at maturity.
Can you keep the bank first and add a private second?
Tiers can also sit side by side on the same property. A homeowner with a low-rate bank mortgage who needs extra funds may be able to leave that first mortgage in place and add a smaller private second, rather than replacing the whole debt with a larger private first. The federal Financial Consumer Agency of Canada notes that a second mortgage is a separate loan, that the first mortgage must still be paid, and that second-mortgage rates are usually higher because they are riskier for lenders. The worked example on this page compares the two routes with illustrative numbers.
In that illustration the second-mortgage route costs less in total because the expensive money is limited to the new funds, even though the private second carries a higher rate and fee and a much higher effective annual cost on its own. The result can flip if the existing first carries only a small penalty or is close to renewal anyway, or if the second's rate and fees are steep relative to the amount borrowed. Test your own figures with the compare-offers tool; for second-mortgage depth, SecondMortgageCalculator.ca goes further.
Which questions help you choose a tier?
You do not pick a tier so much as find out which ones will consider you. A licensed mortgage professional can usually tell you quickly. These questions help you have that conversation:
- What exactly prevents a prime approval today: income documentation, credit, debt ratios, the property or timing?
- Would an alternative lender accept the file if you waited a few months or added documentation?
- If a private loan is the only option now, what is the all-in cost, and what would it take to move up a tier at maturity?
- Is it cheaper to replace the existing mortgage or to add a second behind it, once penalties and fees are counted?
- Who is the actual lender, and how will you receive the commitment, disclosure and payout terms in writing?
Before weighing a B-lender against a private lender, price the private offer properly: here a $500,000 first mortgage on a $700,000 home.
| Loan | $500,000 first mortgage12-month term, interest-only |
|---|---|
| Rate | 9.99%compounded monthly |
| Fees | $17,500lender 2%, broker 1%, other $2,500, deducted from the advance |
| Property | $700,000loan-to-value 71.4% |
| Credit actually advanced | $482,500loan minus every deducted charge |
| APR on credit advanced | 13.76%Criminal Code s.347 limit: 35% |
| If repaid at month 3 | 24.57%fees spread over fewer months |
| All-in effective annual cost | 14.66% |
| Cost of the term | $67,450interest plus fees; $500,000 still owed at maturity |
| Analyzer verdict | Ask before signing1 point to raise |
- Check Fees add 4.2% a year on top of the rate
Open this example in the commitment analyzer →Computed by this site's commitment analyzer (Criminal Code s.347, Interest Act ss.6, 8, 10). Illustrative terms, not an offer.
What does this mean for you?
- Ask a licensed broker whether a B-lender would approve you; if so, compare its all-in cost with the private offer in compare offers before you go private.
- If private is the only option today, set the term to match the moment a bank or B-lender could say yes, and plan the switch from the first month.
- Remember the stress test: federally regulated lenders qualify uninsured borrowers at the higher of the contract rate plus 2 points or 5.25%, so check that payment early.
What do people ask most?
What is a B lender in Canada?
A B lender, or alternative lender, is an institutional mortgage lender such as a trust company or some credit unions with more flexible criteria than a bank. Borrowers typically pay more than prime in exchange for that flexibility.
Is a private lender the same as a B lender?
No. B lenders are institutions working within formal underwriting policies, while private lenders lend their own or investors' capital and decide case by case. Private loans are generally shorter and more expensive.
Can I go straight from a private mortgage back to a bank?
Sometimes, if the reason you could not qualify has been resolved by maturity. Others step through an alternative lender first. Ask what the next lender will need well before your term ends.
Are credit unions banks or B lenders?
It depends on the credit union. Some offer prime mortgages much like banks, while others have alternative-lending programs, so ask about the specific product.
Which primary sources back this page?
This guide is general education for Canadians, not financial, legal or tax advice. Figures in examples are illustrative, not offers or market rates. Rules change; confirm current requirements with a licensed mortgage professional and a lawyer (or notary in Quebec).

