What are the key takeaways?
- The price of a private mortgage combines the contract rate, lender and broker fees, third-party costs and the length of the term.
- Rates move with risk: loan position, loan-to-value, property, borrower profile and the strength of the exit all play a part.
- Upfront fees weigh much more heavily on a short term than a long one, so the same fee can mean a very different effective cost.
- Compare offers on total cost and effective annual cost over the time you actually expect to borrow, not on the rate alone.
What are the parts of a private mortgage price?
Every private mortgage quote can be broken into the same building blocks. Before you compare one offer with another, make sure you have each of these in writing:
- Contract rate. The annual interest rate in the mortgage, plus how it is compounded and whether payments are interest-only or amortizing.
- Lender fee. A one-time charge by the lender for setting up the loan, often expressed as a percentage of the loan and deducted from the advance.
- Broker fee. Compensation for the mortgage broker who arranged the loan, separate from the lender fee; see lender fees and broker fees.
- Third-party costs. Appraisal, the lender's legal fees if you pay them, your own lawyer, title insurance and administration charges.
- Term and structure. How long the loan lasts, whether any interest is prepaid, and what the loan costs to renew or discharge.
- Back-end charges. Renewal, extension, discharge, late-payment and statement fees that may never apply, or may apply several times.
What moves the contract rate?
Private lenders price for risk, and they judge risk mainly through the property and the exit. A loan in first position on a well-located home with plenty of equity behind it is a different proposition from a second mortgage on a rural property where the borrower's exit depends on a future sale. The factors that typically push a quote up or down include:
- Position on title. A second or third mortgage is repaid only after the loans ahead of it, so it usually costs more; see first vs second mortgage position.
- Loan-to-value. The less equity remains after the loan, the thinner the lender's cushion; see loan-to-value in private lending.
- Property type and location. Properties that are harder to value or slower to sell carry more risk for a lender.
- Borrower profile. Credit history, income, experience and the reason for the loan still shape the lender's view.
- Exit clarity. A firm sale agreement or a well-documented refinance plan is easier to price than a hope.
- Size and term. Very small loans may carry proportionally higher costs, and lenders may price shorter or longer terms differently.
Why do fees sit alongside the rate?
Bank borrowers are often surprised that private lenders charge a fee on top of the interest. The logic is that a private loan is short, and the lender does most of its work upfront: reviewing the file, assessing the property, arranging documents and committing capital. If the borrower repays early, the lender may only collect a few months of interest. A fee earned at closing compensates for that setup work and for the chance that the money comes back sooner than planned.
For the borrower, the result is that part of the price is paid on day one whether the loan lasts three months or twelve. That is why the same quote can be reasonable for a full-term loan and expensive for a loan repaid quickly. It is also why fees deducted from the advance reduce the cash you receive while interest still runs on the full registered amount.
How does term length change the math?
The clearest way to see the effect of fees is to hold everything else still and change only the term. The table below uses one illustrative Calgary loan: $650,000 at a 9% contract rate, interest-only, with a 1.5% lender fee, a 1% broker fee and $3,000 of other costs. The first row strips out the fees to show the contract rate alone.
With the same fees spread over six months instead of twelve, the effective annual cost jumps from about 12.9% to about 16.3%, even though the total dollars paid are lower. That is not a contradiction: you pay less in total because you borrow for less time, but you pay much more per year of borrowing. Both numbers are useful, and the guide to effective annual cost explains when to use each.
| Scenario | Total fees and costs | Cash in hand | Total cost of borrowing | Effective annual cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12 months, no fees | $0 | $650,000 | $58,500 | 9.4% |
| 12 months, with fees | $19,250 | $630,750 | $77,750 | 12.9% |
| 6 months, with fees | $19,250 | $630,750 | $48,500 | 16.3% |
How is the interest calculated?
Two loans with the same quoted rate can cost slightly different amounts depending on how interest is compounded. Some mortgages compound interest monthly and others semi-annually, and the commitment should say which applies. On the same illustrative $650,000 at 9% for 12 months, monthly compounding produces an effective contract rate of about 9.4%, compared with about 9.2% if the rate were compounded semi-annually. Ask how interest is calculated, when it is charged and whether it is paid in advance or in arrears.
The law sets some ground rules here. For a mortgage repaid with blended payments, section 6 of the Interest Act says no interest can be charged unless the mortgage states the principal and the interest rate calculated yearly or half-yearly, not in advance, and section 7 limits the lender to that stated rate if other terms would produce more. Separately, section 347 of the Criminal Code makes it an offence to charge more than 35% APR on the credit advanced, where interest includes fees and other charges for the credit; loans to individuals get no commercial exemption from that limit. See Interest Act section 4, criminal interest rate and private loans and cost of borrowing disclosure, and ask your lawyer how they apply to your documents.
How do you compare two offers fairly?
Offers rarely arrive in the same format. One may have a lower rate and a higher fee; another may be longer with a renewal fee built in. To put them on equal footing:
- Write down the net cash each offer puts in your hands on closing day.
- List every fee and cost for each offer, including those payable at renewal or discharge.
- Use the term you realistically expect to need, not the most optimistic one.
- Enter each offer in the true cost calculator and compare total cost and effective annual cost.
- If one offer is cheaper only if everything goes to plan, model a three- or six-month delay with the renewal fee calculator.
What does the price tell you about the loan?
A higher price usually reflects a lender's view of risk, so it is fair to ask what is driving it. Sometimes the answer points to something you can fix, such as a stronger appraisal, a lower loan amount or a firmer exit. Other times it simply reflects the position or the property.
Be cautious when the price is hard to pin down: fees that appear late, costs described only verbally, or requests for money before a written commitment exists. Those are warning signs rather than pricing quirks; the private mortgage red flags guide lists more. This site does not publish rates; for current rate context, PrivateLendingInterestRates.com covers that subject.
A lender offers 9.49% instead of 10.99% but asks a 3% lender fee: the trade most borrowers are offered.
| Loan | $350,000 first mortgage12-month term, interest-only |
|---|---|
| Rate | 9.49%compounded monthly |
| Fees | $18,250lender 3%, broker 1.5%, other $2,500, deducted from the advance |
| Property | $560,000loan-to-value 62.5% |
| Credit actually advanced | $331,750loan minus every deducted charge |
| APR on credit advanced | 15.14%Criminal Code s.347 limit: 35% |
| If repaid at month 3 | 31.45%fees spread over fewer months |
| All-in effective annual cost | 16.24% |
| Cost of the term | $51,465interest plus fees; $350,000 still owed at maturity |
| Analyzer verdict | Ask before signing1 point to raise |
- Check Fees add 6.3% a year on top of the rate
Open this example in the commitment analyzer →Computed by this site's commitment analyzer (Criminal Code s.347, Interest Act ss.6, 8, 10). Illustrative terms, not an offer.
What does this mean for you?
- Never compare offers by rate alone; put both into the true cost calculator for the all-in effective annual cost and the cash you receive.
- Lower loan-to-value and a credible exit are your strongest bargaining points. Bring the appraisal and the exit evidence to the conversation.
- Check what other lenders' books look like on rate ranges: useful context, but never a quote.
What do people ask most?
Why are private mortgage rates higher than bank rates?
Private lenders use their own or investors' capital, take on files banks decline, and lend for short terms, so they price for higher risk and shorter duration. The exact premium depends on the property, position and exit.
Is a lower rate with a higher fee better than a higher rate with no fee?
It depends on how long you keep the loan. Fees weigh more heavily on short terms, so compare both offers over your realistic borrowing period using total cost and effective annual cost.
Can I negotiate a private mortgage rate or fee?
Terms are set lender by lender, and some flexibility may exist, especially if you can reduce risk with more equity or a firmer exit. Ask, and get any changes confirmed in the commitment letter.
What is the difference between the contract rate and the effective annual cost?
The contract rate is the interest rate in the mortgage. The effective annual cost also includes every fee and cost and reflects compounding and the term, so it shows the true yearly price.
Which primary sources back this page?
This guide is general education for Canadians, not financial, legal or tax advice. Figures in examples are illustrative, not offers or market rates. Rules change; confirm current requirements with a licensed mortgage professional and a lawyer (or notary in Quebec).

