What are the key takeaways?
- Effective annual cost combines interest, fees, compounding and timing into one yearly figure based on the cash you actually receive.
- Upfront fees push the effective cost above the contract rate, and the shorter the term, the bigger the gap.
- Total dollar cost and effective annual cost answer different questions; you need both to judge an offer.
- Neither figure includes costs that have not happened yet, such as a renewal fee if your exit runs late.
What is the effective annual cost?
Think of a loan as a set of cash flows. On day one, money arrives in your hands: the loan amount minus any fees and costs deducted at closing. Over the following months, money leaves: interest payments, and at the end, the repayment of the balance plus any discharge fee. The effective annual cost is the single annual rate, compounded, that makes the money in and the money out balance exactly.
Because it starts from the cash you actually received, every deducted fee raises it. Because it is annualized with compounding, it reflects how often interest is charged. And because it spreads the fees only over the months you actually borrow, it rises sharply on short terms. It is the closest thing to an apples-to-apples price for loans with different rates, fees and terms.
Why does the contract rate understate the cost?
The contract rate is the interest rate written in the mortgage. It is an important number, but on a private loan it leaves out three things:
- Fees deducted from the advance. You pay interest on the full registered amount, but you receive less. The guide to lender fees and broker fees shows how that gap arises.
- Compounding. A rate compounded monthly costs slightly more over a year than the same rate compounded semi-annually. The effective figure states that difference openly.
- Term length. A lender fee is paid once, so it is spread over twelve months on a one-year loan but only three on a three-month bridge.
How is the effective annual cost worked out?
You do not need to calculate it by hand, and the true cost calculator does it for you. Still, knowing the steps helps you trust the result and spot when a quoted figure leaves something out:
Prepaid interest changes the first step below. If several months of interest are held back from the advance, the net advance shrinks and the early monthly payments disappear, which nudges the effective annual cost up even though the dollars paid are the same. The guide to prepaid interest and holdbacks shows how large that effect can be, and why it is worth asking whether prepaid interest is refunded if you repay early.
- Start with the net advance: the registered loan minus lender fee, broker fee, other closing costs and any prepaid interest.
- List each payment you will make, month by month, including the final balance and any discharge fee.
- Find the monthly rate at which the present value of all those payments equals the net advance.
- Convert that monthly rate to an annual one with compounding: one plus the monthly rate, raised to the twelfth power, minus one.
- Compare the result with the effective contract rate; the difference is the extra yearly cost created by fees.
How does the term change the cost of one Toronto bridge?
Bridge loans show the term effect most clearly, because they are designed to be short. The table uses one illustrative Toronto bridge loan: $1,200,000 at a 10% contract rate, interest-only, with a 1.5% lender fee, a 1% broker fee and $5,000 of other costs, for $35,000 of fees and costs in total. Only the term changes.
The total dollars rise as the term lengthens, because more months of interest are paid. The effective annual cost moves the other way, because the same $35,000 is spread over more months. A three-month bridge in this illustration costs about 24.5% per year all-in, even though the contract rate is 10%. For bridge-specific planning, see private bridge loans and the bridge exit planner.
| Term | Total interest | Total cost of borrowing | Effective annual cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 months | $30,000 | $65,000 | 24.5% |
| 6 months | $60,000 | $95,000 | 17.4% |
| 12 months | $120,000 | $155,000 | 14.0% |
Should you use effective annual cost or total cost?
The two figures are not rivals; they answer different questions, and confusing them leads to poor decisions.
Total cost of borrowing is the dollar amount you will pay in interest and fees over the loan. It tells you what the loan will take out of your pocket, which matters for budgeting and for deciding whether a project or purchase still makes sense. It naturally rises with longer terms.
Effective annual cost is the price per year of the money. It tells you whether one offer is more expensive than another, independent of term length, and whether borrowing privately is worth it compared with alternatives such as waiting, selling or a cheaper lender. Use it to compare offers covering similar periods, and use total cost to check affordability.
A sensible habit is to look at both together: a loan with a modest total cost but a very high effective annual cost is telling you that the fees are large relative to the time you are borrowing.
What must Ontario brokers disclose under O. Reg. 191/08?
Ontario's Cost of Borrowing and Disclosure to Borrowers regulation, O. Reg. 191/08, is made under the Mortgage Brokerages, Lenders and Administrators Act, 2006. It applies to every mortgage except mortgages where the borrower is not a natural person and mortgages a borrower enters into for business purposes. That scope can include a private mortgage arranged through a brokerage for an individual borrowing for non-business purposes.
The mortgage brokerage must give the borrower a written disclosure statement in plain language. The initial statement must be delivered at least two business days before the earliest of three events: the borrower making any payment other than a disbursement charge, signing the mortgage agreement, or incurring any obligation. The borrower can waive the two days in writing, which is worth thinking about carefully before agreeing to.
For a fixed-rate, fixed-amount mortgage, the statement must include, among other things, the items listed below.
- The principal and the advances.
- The total of all payments, and the cost of borrowing in dollars.
- The term and amortization.
- The annual interest rate and how it is compounded.
- The APR, if it differs from the interest rate.
- The payment amounts, and an amortization schedule.
What does Ontario's APR include and leave out?
Under O. Reg. 191/08, the cost of borrowing includes administrative charges, the lender's lawyer charges payable by the borrower, brokerage charges the borrower must reimburse to the lender, and, in most cases, lender-required appraisal, inspection or survey charges. It excludes prepayment penalties, default charges, registration fees, the borrower's own lawyer and certain insurance charges. Borrower-chosen and borrower-paid title insurance, and appraisals where the borrower receives the report, are also excluded. The APR formula itself is set out in section 3 of the regulation.
Two practical lessons follow. First, the regulated APR may not match a figure from a general calculator, because the inclusion rules are specific. Second, the APR does not capture everything you could end up paying, especially if a loan is repaid early or goes into default, so read those clauses separately; see Interest Act section 8.
What do British Columbia and Nova Scotia require?
In British Columbia, the Mortgage Services Act came into force on October 13, 2026. Under section 7, disclosure and information statements are governed by rules made by the BC Financial Services Authority (BCFSA). Under section 8, an intended mortgagee or purchaser need not advance funds until the required information statement has been provided. The Act also says a mortgage is not void just because a disclosure was missing or defective, so a borrower should not assume a problem with disclosure undoes the loan.
Nova Scotia's consumer page describes rules under the Mortgage Regulation Act. It says a brokerage must give a disclosure form before providing services, and a recommendation-and-assessment form at least one day before the borrower signs or pays. It says lenders must give a disclosure statement at least two days before the borrower signs or pays, covering the cost of borrowing, interest rate, payments, prepayment terms and an amortization table. It also says fees cannot be charged until the borrower has a written funding commitment and a copy of the signed mortgage.
A six-month $350,000 loan at 9.5% with 3.5% of fees: the term effect this guide describes, measured.
| Loan | $350,000 first mortgage6-month term, interest-only |
|---|---|
| Rate | 9.5%compounded monthly |
| Fees | $15,250lender 2%, broker 1.5%, other $3,000, deducted from the advance |
| Property | $600,000loan-to-value 58.3% |
| Credit actually advanced | $334,750loan minus every deducted charge |
| APR on credit advanced | 18.70%Criminal Code s.347 limit: 35% |
| If repaid at month 3 | 27.74%fees spread over fewer months |
| All-in effective annual cost | 20.38% |
| Cost of the term | $31,875interest plus fees; $350,000 still owed at maturity |
| Analyzer verdict | Ask before signing1 point to raise |
- Check Fees add 10.5% a year on top of the rate
Open this example in the commitment analyzer →Computed by this site's commitment analyzer (Criminal Code s.347, Interest Act ss.6, 8, 10). Illustrative terms, not an offer.
What does this mean for you?
- Use the effective annual cost to compare offers of the same term, and the total cost in dollars to see what the term really takes from you.
- Ask for the written cost-of-borrowing disclosure; in Ontario, brokered mortgages to individuals must disclose the APR at least two business days before you sign (waivable in writing).
- If your exit could come early, check the APR at an early payout too; the analyzer shows it.
What do people ask most?
What is the effective annual cost of a mortgage?
It is the yearly rate that accounts for interest, compounding and all fees, measured against the cash you actually receive. It shows the true annual price of the borrowing.
Why is the effective cost higher on a short private loan?
Upfront fees are paid once, so on a short term they are spread over fewer months. That makes each year of borrowing more expensive, even if the total dollars are lower.
Is effective annual cost the same as APR?
Not always. A legal APR counts only the costs its rules include, and the rules differ between banks, Ontario brokerages and the Criminal Code. An all-in effective annual cost includes every cost you enter, so ask how any quoted figure was calculated.
Should I choose the loan with the lowest effective annual cost?
It is a strong starting point for comparing similar offers, but also check total cost, prepayment terms, renewal fees and how realistic your exit is.
Do private lenders have to disclose the APR?
It depends on the province and who arranges the loan. In Ontario, O. Reg. 191/08 requires the mortgage brokerage to give a disclosure statement including the APR where it differs from the rate, for mortgages to individuals that are not for business purposes.
Which primary sources back this page?
This guide is general education for Canadians, not financial, legal or tax advice. Figures in examples are illustrative, not offers or market rates. Rules change; confirm current requirements with a licensed mortgage professional and a lawyer (or notary in Quebec).

